Near the end of my conversation with Garry Ridge on Corey-osity Unleashed, I did something I'd been itching to do for half an hour. I disagreed with him.

He had called WD-40 itself "not sexy." I pushed back. Every workshop I ever ran had one of those blue and yellow cans on the bench. And I bet his 98% of people who loved telling friends where they worked found the place pretty sexy too. Then I said, on the record, I had finally disagreed with somebody I revere.

Garry ran WD-40 Company as CEO for 25 years. He took its market cap from $300 million to $3.6 billion. He has more reasons than most people alive to defend his own opinion.

Here's what he said:

"Well, I accept your disagreement. Thank you."

Seven words. No defense. No "well, what I meant was." No point scored back. He took it, thanked me, and moved on.

I've thought about those seven words ever since, because I've watched hundreds of managers do the opposite.

The Fear Nobody Admits To

Ask a room of managers whether feedback matters and every hand goes up. Ask how many of them went looking for criticism of their own leadership in the last month and the hands drop.

I get it. When you're the manager, asking "how am I doing?" feels like handing over the keys. You worry the team will see a crack. You worry the answer will hurt. Most of all, you worry asking will make you look like you don't know what you're doing... and you got the job because you were supposed to know.

So you don't ask. You run the one-to-one, you cover their work, their blockers, their goals. The conversation never turns around to point at you.

Garry's line on this is blunt. In the interview he told us he coaches eight CEOs at a time, and most of them aren't aware of their behavior and how it affects others. Not most bad CEOs. Most of the CEOs he coaches, people senior enough and keen enough to hire a coach.

My own research found 99.5% of survey respondents had suffered at least one type of bad boss. Ninety-nine point five. I'd bet almost none of those bosses would put themselves in the bad column. They never asked, so nobody told them.

The Gap Between the Two Mirrors

A manager admires a flattering reflection in a hand mirror while his team holds up a larger mirror behind him showing a stressed, less flattering picture

Garry's coaching method starts with awareness, and he borrows it from his friend Marshall Goldsmith. First, the CEO reads What Got You Here Won't Get You There and picks out which of Goldsmith's 20 bad habits apply to them. Then Garry goes to the people around the leader and asks them the same question.

Then he lays the two answers side by side as a heat map. In his words: "Ken, this is what you said. And this is what those you have to lead said."

He describes the gap between the two as "a target rich opportunity." Diplomatic of him.

The research backs him up. Organizational psychologist Tasha Eurich found 95% of people think they're self-aware, but only 10 to 15% are, according to Harvard Business School Online's write-up of her work. Ninety-five percent believe it. Ten to fifteen percent pass the test.

Put those two numbers next to each other and the managers who don't ask stop looking cautious. They look blind.

When Garry shared the feedback with his CEOs, he said the first reaction was often a shrug... "yeah." The surprise came with the next question. Did they know how the behavior landed on other people? No. They had no idea.

Asking Makes You Look Stronger, Not Weaker

Here's the part most managers get backwards.

Back in 1991, Susan Ashford and Anne Tsui studied 387 managers, as seen by their bosses, their peers, and their direct reports, published in the Academy of Management Journal. They looked at how often each manager went looking for feedback, and what kind.

Managers who sought out negative feedback ended up with a more accurate picture of how those three groups rated their work. No surprise there. Ask, and you learn.

The second finding is the one I want every new manager to tape to their monitor. Seeking negative feedback also raised all three groups' opinions of the manager's overall effectiveness.

Read it again. The boss, the peers, and the team all rated the manager higher for asking what they were doing wrong.

The fear says asking costs you authority. The data says the opposite. People respect the manager who goes looking for bad news. They wonder about the one who never does.

I'm not sure about this part: I only verified the study's abstract, not the full paper, so I don't know how big the effect was or whether it held for every type of manager in the sample.

Managers Defend. Coaches Collect.

At WD-40, Garry took the word "manager" out of the company. People reported to their coach. He told us why with a little scene. Picture your first day. Someone walks up and says, "Good morning, I'm your manager." Doesn't feel great. Now picture them saying, "I'm your coach. The only reason I'm here today is to help you play the best possible game."

He also told us 97% of the global team said they respected their coach.

I think the word change did more than rebrand a job title. It changed which direction feedback was allowed to travel.

A manager sees feedback as something you hand down. Coming back up, it feels like insubordination, or worse, a verdict.

A coach sees feedback as information. Every good coach in sport lives on it... the film, the stats, what the players felt out on the field. A coach who refuses to hear how the game felt from the field isn't coaching. They're guessing.

I said this to Garry on the show. In my last three organizations I spent hours trying to convince the managers who reported to me they weren't there to rule with an iron fist. Nobody wanted the conversation. They all wanted to know how to make their people do things. Wrong question every time. I told Garry I wished I'd had his playbook ten years earlier, and I meant it.

The managers asking how to force compliance were never going to ask "how am I doing?" Same fear, wearing two different hats.

The Teacup Rule

An elderly woman speaks frankly to her grown son over china teacups at a kitchen table with Sydney Harbour in the window behind them

The story from the interview I keep coming back to is about Garry's mum.

She lived to 99 years and nine months. Garry was the youngest, born when she was in her forties. Over cups of tea, using a cup and saucer he still keeps in his home, she gave him the feedback he deserved. Feedback, he said, not everyone was brave enough to give him.

The lesson he draws has two halves. You need to be the mother... brave enough to give love and feedback together. And you need to be the son. When feedback arrives, you accept it, say thank you, and move on.

And there it was, in seven words, when I disagreed with him on air. Decades at the top and he still behaves like the son at the tea table.

Most managers fail the son's half. They argue. They explain the context. They go quiet and remember who said it. Every one of those reactions teaches the team a lesson, and the lesson is "don't."

You get one chance with the first piece of honest feedback. Defend yourself and it'll be the last one you hear for a long time.

How to Start Asking

You don't need a heat map or a coach on retainer to begin. Here's what I'd do on Monday.

A team leader leans over a table with a notebook, listening closely as a young engineer speaks frankly and colleagues look on

Pick one behavior, not your whole personality. "How am I doing?" gets you "fine." Choose something specific. Do I interrupt in standups? Do I give clear enough direction on priorities? Do I answer messages late at night and make you feel you should too?

Ask for the negative on purpose. Ashford and Tsui found the benefit in seeking negative feedback, not fishing for compliments. Try "What's one thing I do which makes your job harder?" A question which assumes there's an answer gets you one.

Answer with seven words. Thank them. Write it down. Don't explain, don't justify, don't fix it in the room. If you need to understand it better, ask one follow-up question and stop.

Go back and tell them what you changed. Garry's process ends with returning to the same people after a while and asking again. He put the result simply: "behavior changes when you focus on it." People keep giving feedback when they see it go somewhere.

Ask again. Once is a gesture. A regular habit is a culture. I wrote about scoring your own leadership every evening, and the two habits work well together. The daily questions tell you what you think. Asking your team tells you what they see.

Your Authority Will Survive

Garry calls himself the "Dean of Dumbassery." He calls it a superpower. I think the superpower is simpler than the name. He goes looking for the thing he doesn't know about himself, and he says thank you when he finds it.

Your authority won't collapse because someone on your team tells you you interrupt too much. If anything, the research says it grows.

What does collapse, slowly, is a team whose manager never asks. They stop telling you things. First about you, then about the work, then about the problems heading your way.

So here's my question for you. When was the last time you asked your team what you're getting wrong... and said nothing back but "thank you"?